Army    Air Power    Strategic    Navy    Space


>>
Home

>>
Articles

>>
News

>>
Fact Sheets

>>
Books

>>
Favorite Links

>>
Photo Gallery

>>
Emerging Tech

>>
Discussions



Login
Register

Indian Defense Projects
Indian Space Projects

New Photos


APACHE WAH-64


MIL MI-24


B-52

 

Most Popular Articles
  • Are Indian Fighter Pilots better than US Fighter Pilots?
    The first bilateral dissimilar air combat (DACT) exercise between the U.S. Air Force and the Indian air force in more than 40 years, Cope India 2004, took place at Gawalior, India in Feb this year. Did the IAF pilots out perform the USAF pilots during the exercise.

  • Tejas LCA
    Because of delays in its planned induction, the Tejas does not adequately address the current and future threats faced by the IAF. There is a strong case for encouraging the IAF and ADA to think beyond the Tejas

  • Photos - MiG-29 OVT at MAKS-2005
    Photos of the super maneuverable MiG-29 OVT performing at MAKS 2005



  • Loading


    Previous Next
    Did IAF Air Marshals step out of line?
    Posted by on Thursday, June 11, 2009 (EST)
    Following a protest by China, the Indian Government has pulled up some Air Marshals for making public statement linking the deployment of Su-30 MKI fighters at Tezpur to the Chinese threat.
    Email this page

    Following a protest by China, the Indian Government has pulled up some Air Marshals for making public statement linking the deployment of Su-30 MKI fighters at Tezpur to the Chinese threat. Photo Credit: Andy

    June 11, 2009, (Sawf News) - Following a protest by China, the Indian Government has pulled up some Air Marshals for making public statement linking the deployment of Su-30 MKI fighters at Tezpur to the Chinese threat.

    IAF Air Marshals in the past have also spoken about how India and Pakistan came close to war following the Mumbai terror strike on 26/11, and about the need to activate our advanced landing grounds to cope with the increasing Chinese infrastructure buildup across the LAC.

    So did the Air Marshals really step out of line? I don’t know. What I do know is that I sleep better because of these Air Marshals, one of whom I have had the privilege to fly with in a squadron.

    They are amongst the best the IAF has and are still serving in it, despite the millions that they could accumulate working outside, because they are passionate soldiers. They are in the IAF to defend the country not be politically correct. They are certainly not there to appease the Chinese or the Pakistanis.

    I know that bit about civilian authority and I respect it, just as these Air Marshals do, perhaps with more vigor than me because they still don their uniforms.

    Here are some other thoughts that I have on the issue.

    If the Air Marshals were indeed speaking out of turn, why did the government not pull them up on its own? Why did it act at the behest of China?

    I said earlier that I sleep better because these Air Marshals are serving. I would sleep even better if our Prime Minister had the courage to go wherever our soldiers go, at least in peace time, like to Twang for example.

    Our government is reported to have pulled up the Air Marshals after Chinese officials raised concerns on the sidelines of the Shangri La security dialogue in Singapore from May 29-31.

    Lt Gen Ma Xiaotian, Deputy Chief of General Staff, Peoples Liberation Army, asked Indian delegates including Defense Secretary Vijay Singh and Admiral Sureesh Mehta on the reasons for this sabre-rattling by Indian commanders.

    I think the correct Indian response would have been to tell the Chinese general that our Air Marshals and Generals don’t talk politics, like they do in China. They react to threats and prepare the country to guard against them.

    They should have politely asked the General to ignore any utterances that sound like sabre rattling to the Chinese because a civilian democratically elected government is in charge in India.

    Besides, Vijay Singh could have pointed out that the Chinese infrastructure build up in Tibet goes way beyond sabre rattling – It is noose strung around the Indian neck that the Chinese can tighten anytime.

    News Copyright © Sawf News. May not be reproduced without explicit written permission


     

    Comments:

    China
    By harsha_06 on Friday, June 12, 2009 (EST)
    I dont want to contradict your views here , Mr.Thakur. But sometimes I think it is not good to take decisions with a hot mind.

    I think China didnot even make a sound when they were building infrastructure on their side of border. They did what they think they must do. So I dont see a reason why we must even talk publicly about our moves.

    I think some of us here might have already read this , but here is a link to a report about what China can do.

    http://china.globaltimes.cn/top-photo/2009-06/436320.html

    I hate to say this but China is far superior to India in having influence in global politics. The above report is just a small example. I say the report is total crap and rigged / falsified.

    Like you mentioned , there is noose around Indian neck and it just takes flash of time to tighten it .

    Sometimes it is good to change strategy depending on the enemy.Facing a different enemy needs a different strategy and will.We cannot maintain the same military attitude that we had with Pakistan. We cannot afford to make any decisions in a hot blooded way.

    My conclusion is that I see that it is not wise to go public on our moves against China and must make things happen in a reciprocative way i.e if we do something on our side of border we must make China reciprocate and make them stick to it.

    Actually I was surprised when IAF moved MKI to Kashmir (Jammu Air base I guess), even if it was for a short time and publicly announced it.

    Reply to this Comment
     

    China
    By harsha_06 on Friday, June 12, 2009 (EST)

    In my comments above I was not taking any sides. I dont commend the politicians nor the Air-marshalls.

    Reply to this Comment
     

    Re: China
    By vkthakur on Friday, June 12, 2009 (EST)
    China does not have a free press. If it did, it would ask its Generals the same kind of mostly stupid questions and its Generals would probably give the same kind of straight answers.

    Should we feel sorry that we have a free press?

    Like a lot of other citizens, I am ill at ease about Chinese intentions, with very good reasons, I may say. To me it was reassuring to know that a Su-30MKI squadron is now based in the East. Was it wrong for the press to inform me that is so?

    Big lapses - like the loss of Kashmir, the loss of Aksai Chin and Kargil - have occurred in the past because the government and the country's citizens thought everything was fine, when it was not.

    Should the government not be telling us that things are well and also why they are well? Who is the best person to do so? The politicians or our Generals, Admirals and Air Marshals?

    I don't think there was any sabre rattling. If an Air Marshal had said that we can get the Chinese out of Tibet now that we have the Sukhois in the East that would have been sabre rattling. If an Air Marshal says we can now defend our territorial integrity that is NOT sabre rattling.

    Reply to this Comment
     

    Re:Re:China
    By harsha_06 on Saturday, June 13, 2009 (EST)
    >>>I don't think there was any sabre rattling. If an Air Marshal had said that we can get the Chinese out of Tibet now that we have the Sukhois in the East that would have been sabre rattling. If an Air Marshal says we can now defend our territorial integrity that is NOT sabre rattling.

    I agree to that


    >>>Big lapses - like the loss of Kashmir, the loss of Aksai Chin and Kargil - have occurred in the past because the government and the country's citizens thought everything was fine, when it was not.

    Talk about politicians, I wish they would feel pain if they lose their under-the-table commissions or their seat in assembly or Parliament or even their supporters who stay behind them during elections. Most logical thing to say about them is "Hit them where they feel the pain".

    But i think not all citizens felt everything was fine.Citizens of India evolved during the past 50 years.People now think there is a difference between what is reported in the news/told to them and the ground facts.


    >>>Should the government not be telling us that things are well and also why they are well? Who is the best person to do so? The politicians or our Generals, Admirals and Air Marshals?

    When we can fool/mask the CIA and their satellites when we were conducting the N-tests in 1998 , then why did we counter protests or pressure while making a normal deployment / build-up in NE ?

    I always think there is a way in which things can be handled differently with out raising provocations or protests or international pressure.


    Again, I am not taking any sides or blaming the Air-Marshals

    Reply to this Comment
     

    contd.......
    By harsha_06 on Sunday, June 14, 2009 (EST)

    Did we miss the intelligence part when we are dealing with china ?

    Reply to this Comment
     

    Add Your Comment

    Articles

    News

    Home   |  Articles   |  News   |  Fact Sheets   |  Books   |  Favorite Links   |  Photo Gallery   |  Emerging Tech   |  Discussions